Subscribe | Unsubscribe



October 2012  •  Volume 5 Number 2


A 1.2-meter stress lap performs a polishing run of the LSST tertiary mirror (M3) at Steward Observatory Mirror Laboratory. The M3 is positioned inside the primary mirror annulus ring as part of a single monolith. (Image Credit: Steward Observatory Mirror Laboratory)

Exciting progress has been made on both the LSST primary/tertiary (M1/M3) and M2 mirror systems. Steward Observatory Mirror Laboratory (SOML) has commenced optical polishing of M1/M3, and a formal request for proposal (RFP) bid package was released for the M2 optical fabrication effort.

M1/M3 Moves into Final Optical Polishing

The M1 and M3 surfaces, which share a single monolithic blank with the M3 positioned inside the M1 annulus ring, are beginning to shine (literally) as they move into final optical polishing. Both surfaces have been generated to rough dimension and located in position via a coarse diamond wheel, removing nearly 5 tons of excess material to allow the steep M3 surface to emerge from within the M1 substrate. Next, the surfaces underwent loose abrasive grinding with finer and finer particle sizes to achieve the initial optical shapes (analogous to sanding a piece of wood with finer grit sandpaper). Now, polishing indicates we have finally reached the last optical processing step. However, this milestone also begins the most challenging aspect of optical fabrication as minute levels of material are removed and the surfaces measured to confirm convergence towards the final optical surface quality.

On the left, SOML team members prepare the LSST M3 for optical testing in the test tower. On the right, a view from below shows the SOML test tower bridge structure that supports the optical test equipment for M3. (Image Credit: Steward Observatory Mirror Laboratory)

The polishing process is guided by optical test measurements of the mirror surface taken under the SOML test tower. The photo below left shows preparation for M3 testing (fiducial patches on the mirror relate the test data to the location on the surface). The photo on the right side is a view looking upward to show the bridge structure that supports all the optical test equipment for M3. A similar bridge sits at the very top of the tower supporting the M1 test hardware.

The first optical test data of the M3 surface is shown in the graphic below. This interferogram represents a contour map of the surface, showing the deviation (in height) from the desired final mirror surface. The measurement data is used to determine the next polishing run. The information guides the location and dwell time of the polishing tool to remove small amounts of material, essentially polishing away the high contour areas to make the final smooth optical surface.

An interferogram contour map of the M3 surface shows the deviation (in height) from the desired final mirror surface. The measurement data is used to determine the next polishing run. (Image Credit: LSST Corporation)

Notice the scale of the data is currently in microns of deviation, which certainly is small, but this will eventually become nanometers of deviation as the polishing process is completed. Polishing of M3 and M1 will continue at SOML with final acceptance testing scheduled for late 2013.

M2 RFP Bid Package Released

The Telescope and Site team recently completed a successful M2 Final Design Review in early August to support the release of the RFP for the M2 optical fabrication effort. The baseline scope of work includes polishing the 3.4-meter convex surface and attachment of 78 mirror support pads. Optional scope for the polishing vendor includes the final design and fabrication of the complete M2 Cell Assembly system, consisting of the mirror cell structure, the mirror support system, electronics and sensors, thermal control, and the mirror control system.

The team invested considerable engineering effort to develop a comprehensive baseline system solution to enable a design/build procurement approach. The image below shows a cross section of the M2 Cell Assembly with the integrated M2 (pointing downward). Three rings of actuators comprise the 72 axial supports, which attach to the small pads bonded on the concave backside of M2. These actuators push and pull on the mirror to control the convex mirror shape. Six tangent links around the outer diameter support the transverse loads as a function of zenith angle to minimize stress and deformation in the mirror substrate.

A cross section of the M2 Cell Assembly shows the integrated M2 (pointing downward) and three rings of actuators. The actuators push and pull on the mirror to control the convex mirror shape. (Image Credit: LSST Corporation)

As shown below, the top of the Cell Assembly includes removable panels to enclose the system for thermal control and provides for attachment to the M2 hexapod which aligns the M2 on the telescope mount. The bottom of the Cell Assembly includes aperture rings to define the clear aperture of the M2 and safety stops to prevent any catastrophic damage due to a seismic event. The actuator circular ring geometry enables an efficient steel structure design for the mirror cell. The exploded view of the mirror cell highlights the design features that enable a high natural frequency (to minimize vibration on the telescope), access for maintenance, and clearance holes for cable routing and air flow.

Left: An exploded view of the LSST M2 Cell Assembly shows removable thermal control panels at the top and aperture rings and safety stops at the bottom. The safety stops prevent any catastrophic damage due to a seismic event. (Image Credit: LSST Corporation)

Right: An exploded view of the mirror cell highlights design features that enable a high natural frequency to minimize vibration on the telescope. Clearance holes enable cable routing and air flow. (Image Credit: LSST Corporation)

Laboratory testing of a prototype axial actuator confirmed the performance of the component’s baseline design. (Image Credit: LSST Corporation)

In addition to engineering design and analysis activities, the team performed hardware testing of a prototype actuator. The image to the left shows the baseline actuator design and the prototype axial actuator in a test fixture. Laboratory testing confirmed performance of the component.

Vendor bids are due in early October, with the plan to award the contract to our polishing vendor in early 2013.

Article written by Bill Gressler, LSST Telescope and Site Subsystem Manager


LSST is a public-private partnership. Funding for design and development activity comes from the National Science Foundation, private donations, grants to universities, and in-kind support at Department of Energy laboratories and other LSSTC Institutional Members:

Adler Planetarium; Argonne National Laboratory; Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL); California Institute of Technology; Carnegie Mellon University; Chile; Cornell University; Drexel University; Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory; George Mason University; Google, Inc.; Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics; Institut de Physique Nucléaire et de Physique des Particules (IN2P3); Johns Hopkins University; Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology (KIPAC) – Stanford University; Las Cumbres Observatory Global Telescope Network, Inc.; Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL); Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL); National Optical Astronomy Observatory; National Radio Astronomy Observatory; Princeton University; Purdue University; Research Corporation for Science Advancement; Rutgers University; SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory; Space Telescope Science Institute; Texas A & M University; The Pennsylvania State University; The University of Arizona; University of California at Davis; University of California at Irvine; University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign; University of Michigan; University of Pennsylvania; University of Pittsburgh; University of Washington; Vanderbilt University

LSST E-News Team:

  • Suzanne Jacoby (Editor-in-Chief)
  • Anna Spitz (Writer at Large)
  • Robert McKercher (Staff Writer)
  • Mark Newhouse (Design & Production: Web)
  • Emily Acosta (Design & Production: PDF/Print)
  • Sidney Wolff (Editorial Consultant)
  • Additional contributors as noted

LSST E-News is a free email publication of the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope Project. It is for informational purposes only, and the information is subject to change without notice.

Subscribe | Unsubscribe

Copyright © 2012 LSST Corp., Tucson, AZ •