Science with LSST and Other Large Surveys:
Community Access and Utilization of Future Archives
What will LSST do for You?

University of Washington, Seattle
September 20-22, 2004


Session I: Overview and LSST (8:30 - 10:00)
Chair: Suzanne Hawley, University of Washington

  1. Welcome - Craig Hogan
    Institution: University of Washington
  2. Introduction and Charge - Kem Cook
    Institution: Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, National Optical Astronomy Observatory
  3. LSST SWG Report - Michael Strauss
    Institution: Princeton University
    Title: Towards a Design Reference Mission for the LSST
    Abstract:
    Over the past two years, a group of 19 scientists has been convened by NOAO as a Science Working Group for the LSST concept. We were asked to develop and expand on the science drivers for a telescope system with an etendue of > 200 m2 deg2, without necessarily being tied to any specific design. Our resulting report was delivered in June 2004. In it, we describe the forefront scientific issues to be addressed with such a telescope, ranging over the full scope of science topics to be covered in this conference. I will summarize our report with emphasis on remaining issues, and discuss the future activities of the LSST science working group.
    Full Presentation [PDF 2M]
  4. LSST Science and Design - Tony Tyson
    Institution: UC Davis
    Abstract:
    With an optical etendue of 300 LSST will take 10 sq.deg sky limited images in ten seconds. This enables a broad range of science programs. Each sky patch will be revisited hundreds of times, leading to unique capabilities ranging from precision dark energy constraints to the opening of the "time" window. I will review these science drivers and the design of the facility. The resulting calibrated catalogs and images will be a unique community resource for new investigations.
    Full Presentation [PDF 8.2M]
  5. LSST Corporation and Project Status - Don Sweeney
    Institution: LSST Corporation
    Abstract: none provided
    Full Presentation [PDF 1.5M]
  6. LSST Data Management - Tim Axelrod
    Institution: University of Arizona
    Abstract: none provided
    Full Presentation [PDF 1.1M]

Session II: Previous/Current Surveys - Lessons Learned (10:30 - 12:30)
Chair: Kem Cook, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, National Optical Astronomy Observatory

  1. 2MASS - Roc Cutri
    Institution: IPAC/Caltech
    Title: The 2MASS Data Processing/Archiving System
    Abstract:
    The Two Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS) carried out a highly uniform digital imaging survey of the entire sky in three near infrared bands between June 1997 and January 2001. Survey observations were conducted using a pair of identical 1.3 telescopes on Mt. Hopkins, AZ and Cerro Tololo, Chile, each equipped with a 3-channel infrared array camera. In March of 2003, the primary survey data products derived from the approximately 24.5 TB of raw digital images were released to the astronomical community: 1) a digital Image Atlas containing 4.1 million calibrated FITS images covering the sky; 2) a Point Source Catalog (PSC) containing accurate positions and photometry for ~471 million sources; and 3) an Extended Source Catalog (XSC) that contains accurate positions, photometry and basic shape information for ~1.6 million resolved sources, most of which are galaxies. We discuss how the 2MASS data processing, distribution and archiving systems successfully met the challenges of the large (for the era) data volume, strict science-driven product requirements, and ambitious release schedules of the mission. Key elements of the successful system included well-defined science requirements for the survey, a realistic understanding of the scope and resources required for the job, early integration of the data processing/archiving system into mission planning, a high degree of automation in data processing and quality assurance, and an archiving system designed to provide efficient access and manipulation of the missions massive database tables and image sets. These and other features that will be presented may serve as useful models in planning for the next generation of wide-area surveys.
    Full Presentation [PDF 1.4M]
  2. SDSS - Robert Lupton
    Institution: Princeton University
    Abstract: none provided
    Full Presentation [PDF 3.5M]
  3. RAPTOR/OGLE/ROTSE - Przemyslaw Wozniak
    Institution: Los Alamos National Laboratory
    Title: Data systems and usability in current time domain surveys. What's next?
    Abstract:
    RAPTOR, ROTSE-I and OGLE are examples of surveys with a large ratio of the data collecting power to the aperture diameter of their instruments. I will discuss some of the data processing infrastructure behind these experiments, facilities for public data access they employ and the data usage patterns along with a brief review of the scientific goals and results. The general trend in this type of work is towards handing increasingly complex tasks to autonomous machines. This involves robotization, fully automated data pipelines and real time filtering of interesting events from vast data streams. One potentially interesting direction is customization of alert systems towards users with specific scientific interests through automated subscriber managers. An exciting prospect in transient searches is networking telescopes, databases and subscriber nodes into a wide area sky- and user-aware system constantly interpreting its data and delivering both real-time and historic content.
    Full Presentation [PDF 2.6M]
  4. CFHT - Christian Veillet
    Institution: CFHT
    Title: The CFHT Legacy Survey
    Abstract:
    A general presentation of the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope Legacy Survey: 500 nights of observation over 5 years using the 340 M-pixels 1deg x 1deg MegaCam mosaic camera at the new CFHT prime focus. The main scientific goals will be summarized, and details will be given on the observing strategy, the in-house data processing and the data distribution. A glance at preliminary results after the first year of operation will close the presentation.
    Full Presentation [PDF 8.7M]
  5. QUEST - Charles Baltay
    Institution: Yale University
    Title: The QUEST Surveys
    Abstract:
    The Quest Surveys consist of two phases-Phase1 was QUEST Venezuela that operated with our large format 16 ccd camera at the CIDA Schmidt Telescope from 1998 to 2000,and the Palomar-Quest Variability Survey, using our very large area(3.5 degrees by 4.5 degrees) 112 CCD camera at the Samuel Oshin Schmidt Telescope at Palomar, which started taking science quality data in Aug of 2003.The Cameras, the survey strategies, the data reduction software and the science projects will be discussed.
    Full Presentation [PDF 4.8M]
  6. GRB Afterglows - Shri Kulkarni
    Institution: Caltech
    Abstract: none provided
    Full Presentation [PDF 14K]

Session III: Science from Wide Field Surveys (1:30 - 3:00 p.m.)
Chair: Todd Boroson, NOAO


Session III: Continued (3:30 - 5:00 p.m.)
Chair: Zeljko Ivezic, University of Washington


Session IV: Data Access and Virtual Observatory Models (8:30 - 10:15 a.m.)
Chair: Michael Strauss, Princeton University

  1. IVOA - Peter Quinn
    Institution: European Southern University
    Abstract: none provided
    Full Presentation [PDF 2.9M]
  2. IPAC - Bruce Berriman
    Institution: IPAC,Caltech
    Title: The Architecture of the NASA/IPAC Infrared Science Archive
    Abstract:
    The NASA Infrared Science Archive (IRSA) at the Infrared Processing and Analysis Center (IPAC) curates data from six NASA infrared missions, including the 2MASS 10 TB full resolution image data set and the 1 billion source .working catalog.. This presentation describes the highly-scaleable architecture and algorithms developed at IRSA that support production of these massive data sets, their curation in the archive, their accessibility by the astronomical community, and their interoperability with remote data sets.
    Full Presentation [PDF 890K]
  3. CADC - Luc Simard
    Institution: Herzberg Institute of Astrophysics (NRC-HIA)
    Title: The Canadian Virtual Observatory (CVO)
    Abstract:
    Helping researchers make optimal use of very large datasets in an increasingly multi-wavelength discipline is the primary goal of the Virtual Observatory. In an era populated by a vast array of large surveys at different wavelengths, there is a clear need for such a tool, and this need will become even more acute once facilities such as LSST start producing potentially overwhelming amounts of data. However, the concept of a Virtual Observatory often means different things to different people. In this talk, I will discuss the approach taken at the Canadian Astronomy Data Centre to develop a "data exploration space" that integrates diverse datasets residing at CADC and elsewhere into a common framework that can be used by astronomers working in all regions of the electromagnetic spectrum. Starting from the CVO data model, I will show how different datasets (ROSAT, 2QZ, HST/WFPC2 and CFHT) have already been ingested in a working CVO prototype accessible on the Web.
    Full Presentation [PDF 2.3M]
  4. HST - Rick White
    Institution: STScI
    Title: Lessons for LSST from the Hubble Archive
    Abstract:
    The Hubble Data Archive is quite miniscule in scale compared with the LSST archive, so one might think that the LSST project has little to learn from it. I will however argue that there are some useful lessons for LSST from Hubble. The challenges facing the Hubble archive designers were in fact not so different from those in front of LSST. Design decisions made in the mid-1980s still affect the day-to-day operations of the HDA. Perhaps a little knowledge of our history will help LSST avoid some of the pitfalls that can trap a system in the past.
    Full Presentation [PDF 883K]
  5. NVO - Ray Plante
    Institution: National Center for Supercomputing Applications
    Title: The National Virtual Observatory in the LSST Era
    Abstract:
    LSST's relationship to the National Virtual Observatory (NVO) will be critical to meeting the science needs of our community. I will review the goals and architecture of the NVO as we now see it, and describe how facilities like LSST participate in the federation. This participation can be largely thought of in terms of publishing; I will discuss how the publishing process works today to channel data to working community applications. I will share thoughts on how our expected participation in the NVO should be factored into our data management design. Finally, I will speculate on where NVO will be by LSST's first light and discuss opportunities for leveraging NVO infrastructure to add value to our standard data products.
    Full Presentation [PDF 1.3M]
  6. SDSS - Ani Thakar
    Institution: JHU
    Title: Scalable Data Access for SDSS and the VO
    Abstract:
    I discuss the SDSS data access facilities and Virtual Observatory activities in the context of our ongoing effort to make the SDSS Science Archive an advanced data mining and data intensive science laboratory with solutions that are scalable to the prodigious data rates expected for LSST. The SkyServer is the web portal to the SDSS Catalog Archive Server (CAS) that provides a range of data access tools for novice-to-expert users, including several query tools and a sophisticated image browsing and finding chart service. The SkyServer also incorporates extensive usage and performance logging.

    The SDSS catalog (processed) data is now 3 TB is size and will roughly double by the time the survey is completed. The raw data will be 5-6 times the catalog data in size. While these sizes are small compared to the projected sizes for LSST, our efforts are on track for petabyte-scale data access by the end of the decade. With SDSS DR2, we deployed a batch query system called CasJobs for queue-based query access to the SDSS CAS. We are currently testing parallel data access to SDSS data using a zone-based horizontal data-partitioning strategy within SQL Server, using the MaxBCG cluster-finding algorithm (originally developed by Annis et al.) as a test problem for our "bring the program to the data" approach for data-intensive science. We are also in the process of deploying a 100 TB cluster for turbulence data analysis at JHU.

    On the Virtual Observatory front, we are pursuing several projects aimed at federating and standardizing astronomical data access. We have taken the initiative in proposing and developing the Astronomical Data Query Language (ADQ) standard recently adopted by the International Virtual Observatory Alliance (IVOA). We have developed OpenSkyQuery - an IVOA compliant version of SkyQuery, a distributed query and dynamic cross-matching service that allows any archive to be easily federated in the VO. We have implemented an automated registry as well as all the IVOA-standard web services for access to SDSS data. Finally, we are using the SkyServer traffic logging model as a basis for a VO logging standard.

    Full Presentation [PDF 2.3M]

Session V: Proposed Wide-field Surveys (10:45 a.m.- 12:30 p.m.)
Chair: Chris Stubbs, Harvard University

  1. SNAP - Bill Carithers
    Institution: Lawrence Berkeley National Lab
    Title: The Supernova Acceleration Probe (SNAP)
    Abstract:
    After a brief overview of the SNAP mission, telescope, and instrument suite, we present some details of the planned surveys. These include the deep supernovae discovery survey, the moderately wide weak-lensing survey, and a potential panoramic survey. We will also present the current thinking on SNAP survey data products and data access.
    Full Presentation [PDF 2.2M]
  2. UKIDSS - Steve Warren
    Institution: Imperial College
    Title: The UKIRT Infrared Deep Sky Survey
    Abstract:
    UKIDSS is the next-generation near-infrared sky survey, and will commence in spring 2005, taking 7 years to complete. UKIDSS comprises 5 surveys covering both high and low galactic latitudes, spanning a complementary range of areas and depths. Three relatively shallow surveys cover a total of 7500 sq degs, to K=18.5. The two deep surveys cover 35, 0.8 sq. degs to K=21, 23. The passbands include JHK, as well as the Y band at 0.97-1.07micron, important for some particular science goals. I will describe the survey camera WFCAM, the characteristics of the surveys, the science drivers, the pipeline and archive design, the current status of commissioning of the camera, and the proposed data release timeline.
    Full Presentation [PDF 570K]
  3. Pan-STARRS - Ken Chambers
    Institution: Institute for Astronomy
    Title: PS1 - The Prototype Telescope for the PanSTARRS Array
    Abstract:
    The Institute for Astronomy at the University of Hawaii is developing a large optical synoptic survey telescope system called the Panoramic Survey Telescope and Rapid Response System. The full Pan-STARRS array will consist of four 1.8m telescopes with very large (7 square degree) field of view, giving it an etendue larger than all existing survey instruments combined. Each telescope will be equipped with a 1 billion pixel CCD camera with low noise and rapid read-out, and the data will be reduced in near real time a to produce both cumulative static sky and difference images, from which transient, moving and variable objects can be detected. Pan-STARRS will be able to scan the entire visible sky to approximately 24th magnitude in less than a week, and this unique combination of sensitivity and cadence will open up many new possibilities in time domain astronomy. Pan-STARRS will used to address a wide range of astronomical problems in the Solar System, the Galaxy, and the Cosmos at large. The Pan-STARRS Telescope No. 1 (PS1) is the prototype telescope for the Pan-STARRS project and is scheduled to begin construction at Haleakala Observatories in the fall of 2004 with first light in January 2006. A description of the PS1 site, capabilities, and design reference mission will be presented.
    Full Presentation [PDF 7.5M]
  4. QUEST - George Djorgovski
    Institution: Caltech
    Abstract: none provided
    Full Presentation [PDF 2.4M]
  5. TAOS - Matt Lehner
    Institution: CfA/UPenn
    Title: The Taiwanese-American Occultation Survey (TAOS)
    Abstract:
    TAOS is a program dedicated to performing a survey of small objects (<10 km) in the trans-Neptunian Region of the Solar System by detecting the occultations of bright stars by these objects. This survey must deal with the low expected event rate, marginal signal to noise of detections at one telescope, and the possibility of a high false detection rate due to atmospheric fluctuations or other terrestrial phenomena. TAOS responds to these challenges with an array of small (50 cm) telescopes, each equipped with a 2048x2048 pixel CCD camera, which will operate automatically to monitor ~2000 stars simultaneously at 5 Hz. In this talk, an overview of the survey and the current status of the system will be presented, and plans for public data access will be discussed.
    Full Presentation [PDF 2.0M]
  6. DES - Mike Gladders
    Institution: Carnegie Observatories
    Abstract: none provided
    Full Presentation [PDF 1.3M]
  7. VST/VISTA/EST - Luiz da Costa
    Institution: European Southern Obs.
    Title: The ESO Imaging Survey Project: Building a Survey Software System
    Abstract:
    To cope with the rapidly increasing volume and complexity of data being generated by ESO's public optical/infrared imaging surveys a high-performance, end-to-end survey software system has been developed. Its main aim is to provide a robust framework to efficiently transform raw data into science-grade survey products. The system consists of several tasks wrapped together into an integrated framework. These tasks include: the un-supervised reduction of optical/infrared images generated by different imagers, the astrometric and photometric calibration of the data, the creation of image stacks and mosaics, the preparation of catalogs and the selection of different targets of potential interest for spectroscopic follow-up. Since the data are meant to be public, the system also provides an extensive description of the products and the required information for users to assess their quality. The system has been designed to enable a small group to monitor the un-supervised reduction and analysis of data from multiple surveys in their entirety -- from survey definition all the way through to the release of comprehensively documented survey products (stacked images, mosaics and catalogs) -- all done by one operator from a single desktop. While originally designed for handling survey data, the system can also be used as a general front-end to ESO's raw data archive, and as such serve as a site-specific interface to the general VO infra-structure. In this contribution the system is briefly described.

Session V: Continued (1:30 - 2:00 p.m.)
Chair: Tony Tyson, UC Davis

  1. Destiny - Tod Lauer
    Institution: NOAO
    Title: DESTINY - The Dark Energy Space Telescope
    Abstract:
    We describe a mission concept for a 2-meter class near-infrared (NIR) grism-mode space telescope optimized to return richly sampled Hubble diagrams of Type Ia and Type II supernovae (SNe) over the redshift range 0.5 < z < 1.7$ for determining cosmological distances, measuring the expansion rate of the Universe as a function of time, and characterizing the nature of dark energy. The central concept for our proposed Dark Energy Space Telescope (DESTINY) is an all-grism NIR survey camera. SNe will be discovered by repeated imaging of an area located at the north ecliptic pole. Grism spectra with resolving power R=75 will provide broad-band spectrophotometry, redshifts, SNe classification, as well as valuable time-resolved diagnostic data for understanding the SN explosion physics. Our approach features only a single observing mode with no time-critical operations, a single detector technology, and a single instrument. Although grism spectroscopy is slow compared to SN detection in any single broad -band filter for photometry, or to conventional slit spectra for spectral diagnostics, the multiplex advantage of observing a large field-of-view over a full octave in wavelength simultaneously makes this approach highly competitive.
    Full Presentation [PDF 680K]
  2. DCT - Ted Bowell
    Institution: Lowell Observatory
    Title: Lowell Observatory's Discovery Channel Telescope
    Abstract:
    Lowell Observatory is developing a 4.2-m wide-field telescope having significant capabilities for solar system and broad spectrum astronomical research. The Discovery Channel Telescope (DCT) will be able to switch rapidly between 2-deg-FOV imaging using a prime-focus camera and 30-arcmin-FOV instruments at Ritchey-Chretien focus. The DCT is to be located 65 km SSE of Flagstaff, Arizona, at 2360 m altitude. The site produces year-round median image quality of 0.84 arcsec, with a first-quartile averaging 0.61 arcsec. The DCT will feature active optics and alignment capability, and the prime focus camera will contain 40 2k x 4k CCDs. The maximum RC instrument payload of about 2300 kg will be suitable for large instruments or suites of co-mounted instruments. Preliminary mechanical and optical designs have been completed, and a concept design review took place in July 2004. First light is currently scheduled for 2009. The telescope is being developed in partnership with Discovery Communications, Inc., which will use it and the association with Lowell Observatory to devise educational programming about astronomy and technology. Lowell Observatory is seeking additional partnerships for DCT.
    Full Presentation [PDF 9.1M]

Session VI: Facilities for Follow-up (2:00 - 3:00 p.m.)
Chair: Tony Tyson, UC Davis

  1. Large Telescopes/Instruments - Jeremy Mould
    Institution: NOAO
    Title: Large Telescopes/Instruments
    Abstract:
    Every night LSST is expected to survey over 3000 sq deg and compare objects brighter than 24th magnitude with a template image. The demand for spectroscopic followup of supernovae, gamma ray bursters, novae, and active galactic nuclei will confront the available resources of the U.S. system: IMACS, GWFMOS, Hectospec, MODS, HET's spectrographs and their successors. To plan to make the most of this opportunity, we should develop the capability to followup LSST's precursors: PanStarrs and the Dark Energy Camera. There will also be a need for imaging follow-up to supplement the LSST's limited cadence.
    Full Presentation [PDF 4.7M]
  2. Small Telescope Networks - Charles Bailyn
    Institution: Yale University
    Abstract: none provided
    Full Presentation [PDF 15.9K]
  3. The Telescope System - Keivan Stassun
    Institution: Vanderbilt University
    Title: Photometric Searches for Young, Eclipsing Binary Stars
    Abstract:
    We describe an ongoing, large-scale program to search for young, eclipsing binary stars. Once identified, these rare systems are followed up with intensive photometric monitoring on small telescopes and spectroscopic monitoring on large telescopes. The fundamental stellar parameters derived from these systems (masses, radii, luminosities) can be used for stringent tests of pre-main-sequence stellar evolution models, for calibrating the stellar initial mass function, and for constraining the timescale for planet formation.
    Full Presentation [PDF 2.5M]
  4. Microlensing Followup - Dave Bennett
    Institution: University of Notre Dame
    Title: Time Critical Follow-up of Microlensing Events: Lessons for LSST
    Abstract:
    Much of the success of the microlensing projects of the past decade has been enabled by the "alert" or "early warning" systems that allow the discovery of microlensing events while they are in progress. These alert systems have much in common with a system that will be needed for the detection of transients with LSST, and I will discuss the implications of the microlensing experience for LSST planning.
    Full Presentation [PDF 287K]

Session VII: Breakout Groups (3:30 - 5:30 p.m.)
Group 1 - Solar System (Chair: Zeljko Ivezic, University of Washington)
Group 2 - Galactic (Chair: Kem Cook, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, National Optical Astronomy Observatory)
Group 3 - Extragalactic (Chair: Todd Boroson, NOAO)


Session VIII: Breakout Group Presentation (8:30 - 9:30 a.m.)
Chair: Craig Hogan, University of Washington

  1. Solar System - Zeljko Ivezic
    Institution: University of Washington
    Full Presentation [PDF 335K]
  2. Galactic - Kem Cook
    Institution: Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, National Optical Astronomy
    Full Presentation [PDF 9K]
  3. Extragalactic - Todd Boroson
    Institution: NOAO
    Full Presentation [PDF 10K]

Summary Talks (9:30 - 12:00 p.m.)
Chair: Suzanne Hawley, University of Washington